73 stackexchange-grounded, 516 model-knowledge (ESCO-seeded gemma3), 0 review_needed (calibration caveat documented). Adapters rebuilt with the full competence sets; final REPORT numbers; all verify checks pass. Known gap: engineering-manager lacks an ESCO package counterpart. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01PDKeXvpT6tENSvyQGLV1Uq
62 lines
26 KiB
JSON
62 lines
26 KiB
JSON
{"job_id": "eP5MowbPnC65OM7rAAAAAA==", "relevant": true, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad explicitly seeks an 'Applications Specialist' with a focus on chemistry analyzers, which aligns directly with the target occupation of 'chemical application specialist'. The description details development and support related to chemical products/analyzers and their applications - core re", "title": "Applications Specialist Chemistry Analyzers - Horsham, PA"}
|
||
{"job_id": "Bf4F8A6cVsKQwlIZAAAAAA==", "relevant": true, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad focuses on developing application expertise for chemical products (lubricants), providing technical support related to product application, and improving processes - all core activities of a 'chemical application specialist' as defined by ESCO. The title includes \"Process Application Spec", "title": "Process Application Specialist, Can and Beverage Lubricants"}
|
||
{"job_id": "-TKdXdroVzcfVWmSAAAAAA==", "relevant": true, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad focuses on developing application expertise at customer sites, providing technical support related to product application, and improving formulations/processes - all core activities of a chemical application specialist as defined by ESCO. The title 'Process Application Specialist' is a re", "title": "Process Application Specialist, Can and Beverage Lubricants"}
|
||
{"job_id": "iiMk5lHzvZls-GP9AAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a technology specialist within a patent law firm. This role focuses on understanding and explaining technical concepts to legal professionals, not developing chemical formulations or evaluating their performance as defined in the ESCO definition of a Chemical application specialist", "title": "Technology Specialist; Chemistry"}
|
||
{"job_id": "WJvd8DwBvJ7j3DauAAAAAA==", "relevant": true, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad title 'Research And Development Chemist' aligns closely with the target occupation and its synonyms (product development chemist, formulation development engineer, development chemist). The opening describes R&D activities which directly relate to developing chemical products and formulat", "title": "Research And Development Chemist"}
|
||
{"job_id": "xs2QeAG2wh1kt7VHAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad opening is generic company boilerplate and does not mention any chemical application or formulation work. The title 'Chemist III' is too broad; while a chemical application specialist *is* a chemist, a Chemist III could be doing many things unrelated to the target occupation. There is no ", "title": "Chemist III"}
|
||
{"job_id": "ZbG7ZO_TPBZSzvJLAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad focuses on sample management and reagent logging - tasks of a lab technician or assistant, not formulation development or performance evaluation as defined in the ESCO definition for a chemical application specialist. The description does not mention any activities related to developing c", "title": "Associate Scientist / Chemist"}
|
||
{"job_id": "JEgHomIBCWw5b5oMAAAAAA==", "relevant": true, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job description explicitly mentions 'formulation' which is a key activity of a chemical application specialist (as per the ESCO definition). The opening also highlights contribution to formulation, synthesis and characterization - all relevant tasks. While the title includes 'Research Chemist', ", "title": "PhD Research Chemist"}
|
||
{"job_id": "tWJeL9Y8Fdp1FFebAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a \"Quality Scientist\", which focuses on ensuring product quality rather than *developing* chemical formulations as described in the ESCO definition of a Chemical Application Specialist. While chemistry is involved, the core function is quality control/assurance, not formulation dev", "title": "Quality Scientist II (Chemistry)"}
|
||
{"job_id": "LiT2lanuhqka2acjAAAAAA==", "relevant": true, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad explicitly focuses on 'formulation development' which is a core activity of a chemical application specialist (as per the ESCO definition). The description details work with polymers, coatings and resins - all areas where formulation expertise would be directly applied. While the title in", "title": "R&D Chemist / Materials Scientist — Photopolymers, Coatings, Foams & Ceramic 3D Printing"}
|
||
{"job_id": "Nq-LdGPP6qWebTt6AAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a Quality Control Chemist, which focuses on ensuring product quality *after* formulation. The target occupation (chemical application specialist) focuses on the *development* of those formulations themselves. While both roles involve chemistry, they are distinct functions within a ", "title": "Quality Control Chemist"}
|
||
{"job_id": "ivLQEN7TcpCoHPz7AAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "blocklist", "reason": "role family: instructor", "title": "Chemist- Operational Trainer"}
|
||
{"job_id": "BuElGky8jb-ro1qzAAAAAA==", "relevant": true, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job title is a direct synonym of the target occupation (product development chemist/formulation development engineer/development chemist). The opening describes work related to chemical formulations and coatings which aligns with the ESCO definition.", "title": "Product Development Chemist"}
|
||
{"job_id": "I_QRqaWMLg9D1hfUAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a 'Carwash Chemical Technician', focused on car wash cleaning solutions. While it involves chemicals, the specialization (car washes) and the context of equipment/service provision do not align with the broader definition of a 'Chemical application specialist' who develops chemical", "title": "Carwash Chemical Technician - Virginia"}
|
||
{"job_id": "-0oJmJp7SCwT3xPDAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a 'Chemical Manufacturing Technician', which focuses on production rather than formulation *development* as defined in the ESCO definition of a Chemical Application Specialist. While it involves chemicals and APIs, the role centers around manufacturing processes, not developing new", "title": "Chemical Manufacturing Technician II - Active Pharmaceutical Ingredients"}
|
||
{"job_id": "GPJ06Qt7gJnlKRujAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a 'Lab Technician I' which is a different role family than a 'chemical application specialist'. While it mentions chemistry and microbiology, the technician role focuses on lab work and testing rather than formulation development or product application as defined in the ESCO defini", "title": "Lab Technician I (MD): Microbiology/Chemistry Degree Required"}
|
||
{"job_id": "M2P8QWhmaVSDy7J1AAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a Field-Service Technician, which focuses on servicing equipment related to chemical products, not developing or formulating them as a Chemical Application Specialist would. The description details application *of* chemistry, but the role itself isn't about creating it.", "title": "Field-Service Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "s91yoRhwjvO9W6JKAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad describes a technician applying existing chemical treatments in landscaping, focusing on pest control. This is distinct from *developing* chemical products or formulations as defined by the ESCO definition of a Chemical Application Specialist (or its synonyms). The role focuses on applica", "title": "Landscape Spray Technician - Chemical Applications Expert"}
|
||
{"job_id": "4Y6nJAUXSGcMDMhYAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad title is 'Associate Analytical Technician'. While analytical techniques are *used by* chemical application specialists, this role focuses on analysis itself, not formulation or development of chemical products as defined in the ESCO definition. The opening text does not indicate a shift t", "title": "Associate Analytical Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "NB3S3sYAl6hfY3kJAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a 'Gas Chemical Technician' supporting semiconductor projects. While it involves chemicals, the focus is on gas handling within semiconductor manufacturing, not developing chemical *products* or *formulations* as defined in the ESCO definition of a chemical application specialist. ", "title": "Gas Chemical Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "1cjL6fVSlMm3Ed8xAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad title is 'Associate Chemistry Technician', which does not match any of the target occupation titles (chemical application specialist or its synonyms). The opening paragraph focuses on company values and a general career pitch, offering no indication that this role involves developing chem", "title": "Associate Chemistry Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "lfusDNf-AUb9s-IqAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad title is 'Senior Laboratory Technician'. While lab technicians work *in* chemistry, this role does not match the ESCO definition of a chemical application specialist (or any synonym). The opening focuses on company values and broad statements about chemistry, but doesn't describe the spec", "title": "Senior Laboratory Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "G4X9Y1IEA6mBrDngAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a 'Lab Technician', which is a different role family than a 'Chemical Application Specialist'. While both roles work in a lab and use chemistry, a Lab Technician performs general testing and analysis, whereas a Chemical Application Specialist *develops* chemical products and formul", "title": "Lab Technician I - General Chemistry"}
|
||
{"job_id": "r6En2-JKzCdwlGa_AAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a 'Laboratory Technician' which is a different role than any of the target occupations (chemical application specialist or its synonyms). While laboratory work *may* be performed by someone in those roles, this ad focuses on routine testing and sensory evaluation - typical tasks fo", "title": "Laboratory Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "ySZ8isUoUS3TtcNvAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a Quality Control Lab Technician, which focuses on *testing* existing products to ensure quality. This is distinct from developing new chemical formulations or evaluating their performance, which are the core responsibilities of a Chemical Application Specialist (or its synonyms). ", "title": "Quality Control Lab Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "mqCVugNjQ5ZeTgjeAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a 'Pilot Plant Technician', which is an operations/manufacturing role focused on scaling up chemical processes, not developing formulations or evaluating performance as defined in the ESCO definition of a Chemical Application Specialist. While it's *in* a chemical environment, the ", "title": "Pilot Plant Technician Job"}
|
||
{"job_id": "HF_gmK_ss3CyjT-EAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad title is 'Laboratory Technician', which is a different role than any of the target occupations (chemical application specialist or its synonyms). While a chemical application specialist *might* work in a laboratory, this ad does not describe that specific role; it describes a general lab ", "title": "Laboratory Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "7atPBqBLKXhkYLBfAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad focuses on lab management and inventory control ('Chemical Processing Center Technician'). This is a technician role supporting chemical processes, not someone *developing* formulations or evaluating their performance as defined in the ESCO definition for 'chemical application specialist'", "title": "Chemical Lab Processing Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "zteazwrtqi2EhUhPAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad title is 'Process Control Technician', which does not match any of the target occupation titles or synonyms (chemical application specialist, etc.). While the opening mentions chemistry and product development broadly, the title indicates a role focused on process control - a different fu", "title": "Process Control Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "-AIj8I6xhbw8j45ZAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad focuses on *application* of chemicals via spraying, and chemical safety - a technician role. The target occupation is about *developing* chemical products and formulations. While application might be part of testing developed formulas, this ad describes a hands-on application/technician r", "title": "Chemical Spray Technician - Bilingual (EN/ES)"}
|
||
{"job_id": "qLjCLWNzDgMIzsjhAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad title is 'Chemical Technician', which while related to chemistry, does not match any of the target occupation titles (chemical application specialist or its synonyms). The opening focuses on Avery Dennison's broader business and doesn't indicate a role focused on *developing* chemical for", "title": "Avery Dennison Hiring Event - Chemical Technician - 2nd Shift"}
|
||
{"job_id": "-oBOBMOUqkiD_QqBAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad title is \"Chemical Manufacturing Technician\", which focuses on *manufacturing* rather than *development* of chemical formulations as described in the ESCO definition for a Chemical Application Specialist. The opening paragraph further emphasizes manufacturing and lubrication products, not", "title": "2nd Shift Chemical Manufacturing Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "ibRL4LpvUh0A0XJCAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad title is \"Chemical Manufacturing Technician\", which describes a role focused on *producing* chemicals, not *developing* them as defined in the ESCO definition for Chemical application specialists. The opening text further reinforces this focus on manufacturing and company background rathe", "title": "Chemical Manufacturing Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "hcbrdJ9fI0Opoj3TAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a \"Chemical Service Technician\" which focuses on *service* of chemical products in an oilfield setting. The target occupation (chemical application specialist/chemist) focuses on the *development and formulation* of those chemicals. While both roles work with chemicals, they are di", "title": "Chemical Service Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "xWPDVJ0PYLlb76_nAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad title is \"Chemical Laboratory Technician\", which is a different role than any of the target occupations (chemical application specialist or its synonyms). While it requires a chemistry background and involves industrial chemistry, the description focuses on *analysis* of existing compound", "title": "Chemical Laboratory Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "OIuTR6n63OzyDQ0EAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a technician who *applies* chemicals (spraying), but not someone who *develops* chemical formulations or evaluates their performance as defined in the ESCO definition. This role focuses on application and maintenance of equipment, not formulation chemistry.", "title": "Nursery Spray Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "tfniXpF7qkxPUL4rAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a laboratory technician, which prepares equipment and supports experiments. This is distinct from developing chemical formulations and evaluating their performance as described in the official definition of a 'chemical application specialist'. While chemistry is involved, the role ", "title": "Chemistry and Science Laboratory Technician PT Main Campus"}
|
||
{"job_id": "XprdYRzpRUGHJ_V-AAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a QC Lab Technician, which focuses on quality control testing. This is distinct from developing chemical products or formulations as described in the official definition of a Chemical Application Specialist/Specialist Chemist. While chemistry knowledge is required, the role does no", "title": "QC Lab Technician - Chemistry (Rotating Shifts, Contract)"}
|
||
{"job_id": "SYlNMWBa-EgeDxHYAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a Maintenance Technician, which focuses on maintaining equipment in a chemical plant. This is distinct from developing chemical products or formulations, which is what a Chemical Application Specialist does. The skills and responsibilities described are those of an engineering/main", "title": "Maintenance Technician for a chemical plant"}
|
||
{"job_id": "9gv_EZvwbfWsSpl2AAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a 'Technician' role providing basic support to scientists. While it's in an R&D chemistry lab, the technician role is distinct from developing formulations and evaluating performance - which defines the target occupation. The title explicitly states 'Tech', not 'Chemist' or any syn", "title": "Junior R&D Chemistry Lab Tech"}
|
||
{"job_id": "mwAvaQGucDkXQZXmAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a 'Chemical Manufacturing Technician', which focuses on production and record-keeping within manufacturing processes. This is distinct from the target occupation of a 'Chemical application specialist' who *develops* chemical products and formulations. While both roles work with che", "title": "Chemical Manufacturing Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "X6q6Dd1Fk55ObBXFAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a Mechanical Technician specializing in fired engine testing. While Afton Chemical Corporation deals with chemicals (lubricant additives), this role focuses on the mechanical aspects of *testing* those products, not developing or formulating them. The description centers around bui", "title": "Mechanical Technician - Fired Engine Testing"}
|
||
{"job_id": "92hTubeWd9gaXdApAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a 'Quality Lab Technician', which focuses on testing and ensuring existing products meet standards. This is distinct from developing *new* chemical formulations or application processes as described in the target occupation definition (developing formulas, evaluating efficiency of ", "title": "Quality Lab Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "YD7RDBfJ0JUE-iNUAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad title is \"E&I Technician\" which stands for Electrical & Instrumentation Technician. This is a completely different role than any of the target occupations (chemical application specialist and its synonyms). The opening paragraph broadly discusses chemistry but does not indicate that the p", "title": "E&I Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "4ydlHomGJyTTIWySAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for \"Laboratory Technicians\", which is a broader role than any of the target occupations. While chemistry is involved, the technician role does not focus on *developing* chemical applications or formulations as defined in the ESCO definition. It's a support role within a lab, not the s", "title": "Laboratory Technicians, Chemistry"}
|
||
{"job_id": "5xObTrIDcScjPvqTAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a pesticide technician who *applies* chemicals, but does not *develop* or *formulate* them. The ESCO definition focuses on development and evaluation of formulations, which are absent from the listed duties. This role is about application, not formulation.", "title": "Spray Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "FUNqUl-lN6Iops9iAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a Quality Control Lab Technician, which focuses on *testing* existing samples to ensure compliance with standards. This is distinct from developing new chemical formulations and evaluating their performance, as described in the official definition of a Chemical Application Speciali", "title": "Quality Control Lab Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "zCSxP6kZz3Dv7I1RAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a 'Quality Lab Technician', which focuses on testing and ensuring existing products meet standards. This is distinct from developing new chemical formulations or evaluating their performance, as described in the official definition of a Chemical Application Specialist/Specialist Ch", "title": "Quality Lab Technician (Mitsubishi Chemical Advanced Materials)"}
|
||
{"job_id": "dUcRbDgBM8ehu9axAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a \"Chemistry Laboratory Technician\", which is a different role than any of the target occupations (chemical application specialist or its synonyms). The opening describes an educational setting and does not mention chemical formulation, product development, or client needs - core a", "title": "Chemistry Laboratory Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "Swir65ON_fDr88yTAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a swimming pool service technician focused on maintenance (vacuuming) and basic water chemistry balancing. This does not involve developing chemical *products* or *formulations*, evaluating their performance, or conducting formulation processes – all core activities of a Chemical A", "title": "Experienced Swimming Pool Service Technician – Vacuuming & Chemical Balancing"}
|
||
{"job_id": "Z5fZSCM_Pjt081DQAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a lab technician supporting lab services and safety, focused on preparation and maintenance. This is a support role *within* a chemistry environment, not someone developing chemical products or formulations as defined by the target occupation.", "title": "Chemistry Student Lab Technician - PLV"}
|
||
{"job_id": "qZgFdvhhYXst67GEAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad focuses on *performing* chemical cleaning services in the field (a technician role), not *developing* chemical formulations or processes (the core of a chemical application specialist). The opening describes service work and cleaning operations, not product development. While chemicals ar", "title": "Field Service Technician/Field Service Application Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "hpu7CMmQZd9sUBhjAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad title is 'Lab Technician', which does not match any of the target occupation titles or synonyms. The opening describes the company's technology but doesn't indicate a role focused on chemical formulation development or application - it focuses on the *technology* itself, not someone who *", "title": "Lab Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "zHv73H_qKt347wdGAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a \"Chemistry Laboratory Technician\", which is a support role *within* a chemistry environment but not someone who develops chemical products or formulations as defined by the target occupation. The description focuses on supporting teaching and learning within a college setting.", "title": "Chemistry Laboratory Technician (A12)"}
|
||
{"job_id": "KC-7R63hlcVOUQLYAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a 'Lab Technician', which is a different role family than a 'Chemical Application Specialist'. While lab work is *involved* in the target occupation, this position focuses on standardized testing and adherence to procedures rather than formulation development or client needs - core", "title": "Lab Technician I - Respirator Use"}
|
||
{"job_id": "6zuL45xjwF9cgcygAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a Quality Control Lab Technician, which focuses on testing and ensuring quality of materials - not developing chemical formulations or application as defined in the target occupation's definition. While it involves analytical chemistry, this is a supporting role to manufacturing, n", "title": "Quality Control Lab Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "Par2_UOKNlPqS1VBAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad describes a role focused on chemical safety and inventory management within a laboratory setting. This is distinctly different from developing chemical products or formulations, which is the core function of a Chemical Application Specialist as defined in the ESCO definition. The opening ", "title": "Chemistry Safety Tech"}
|
||
{"job_id": "UmqLzX3FX6nnbtPqAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a 'Spray Technician' focused on *applying* existing chemical solutions for pest/weed control (IPM). The target occupation ('chemical application specialist') focuses on *developing* those formulations and evaluating their performance - a fundamentally different role. While the tech", "title": "Spray Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "VsPp8zmBUp_9BSgbAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a technician applying *existing* mosquito control products, not developing or formulating them. This role focuses on application of pre-made solutions, while the target occupation involves formulation and development of chemical products.", "title": "Mosquito Pesticide Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "DXBXACEI6QQ7ug9SAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad is for a technician who *applies* fertilizer and pesticides, not someone who *develops* chemical formulations. This is an application role, not a development/formulation role as defined in the ESCO definition.", "title": "Fertilizer/Pesticide Technician"}
|
||
{"job_id": "Sg4xy-lisHkR0bHTAAAAAA==", "relevant": false, "stage": "llm", "reason": "The job ad describes a technician role at a power plant focused on operating and maintaining gas turbines and steam generators. This is unrelated to developing chemical products or formulations as defined in the ESCO definition for a Chemical Application Specialist.", "title": "Performance Technician"}
|